Washington Publishers

Tallahassee Florida

Click here to visit our Parenting Forum

John Rosemond - Parenting Expert

John Rosemond is America's most widely-read parenting authority! He is a best-selling author, columnist, speaker, and family psychologist.

Index | Archives | About John Rosemond | Books | Submit A Question

Five-year-old is not manipulative

Q: My 5-year-old son was so nervous on the first day of kindergarten that he threw up shortly after getting there. Since then, he's been crying every morning about having to ride the bus that many of his classmates also ride. He cries on the way to the bus stop, cries while he's waiting, and I have to almost literally push him on it when it arrives. I have to admit that at least one morning a week I've given in and driven him to school. Each time I do so, he promises me that if I'll take him "just one more time," he'll willingly ride the bus from then on. Needless to say, his promises are empty. When I ask him what he's afraid of, he can't tell me, and his teacher says he's fine by the time he gets to school. A counselor friend of mine says my son's manipulating me. What do you think?

A: The idea that children manipulate their parents has been vastly overblown. It implies a mental maturity and more importantly, an ability to analyze human behavior that 5-year-old children do not possess and won't possess for, at best, several years to come. No, a young child who's crying every morning about riding the bus to school isn't trying to manipulate—as in conspiring against one's parents with aforethought; he's genuinely upset.

Your son is really scared, but there are two kinds of really scared. In the first, the child is afraid of an event that has happened or might well happen. Your son's fear would fall into this category if, for example, the bus had been struck by a truck and turned on its side the first morning he rode it. In this case, his fear would be reality-based and would merit some protective action on your part. (Tangent: Do you know that the government seat belt law, especially as it pertains to children, can be legally ignored only by the government, as in on school buses? I encourage my readers to put pressure on local schools to install seat belts, with shoulder harnesses, in school buses.)

The second kind of really scared involves either (a) a fear of something that has never happened and has a slim to none chance of ever happening or (b) a vague, undefined feeling of fear which the child can't put words to (i.e., "I'm just afraid!"). Based on your description, I'm reasonably certain your son's fear falls under (b). He's obviously not afraid of school itself or the teacher would be seeing evidence of that in the classroom. If he hasn't already, the bus driver will probably tell you your son calms down by the time the bus reaches the next stop.

I'm sure you've said everything you can possibly say to your son about his fear. You've done what you can to help solve the problem, now it's his turn. In fact, your son is the only person who can solve this problem, and believe me, an otherwise emotionally healthy 5-year-old is completely capable of bringing a fear of this sort under control.

Tell your son that he simply must ride the bus every morning. You'll continue to walk him to the bus stop (which you should do regardless) and wait with him until the bus arrives, but you will not drive him to school again, period. Assure him that it's all right to cry and give him full permission to do so. Tell him that sometimes crying helps people get over fears of this sort. Don't promise him anything special if he doesn't cry, and don't make a big deal of it the first morning he is successful at "sucking it up." On that auspicious day, just tell him you're proud of him and let that be it. After all, getting on the bus without tears is no big deal.

If your son sees firm resolve on your part concerning this matter, this too should pass within a relatively short period of time.

This web page is best viewed in 1024 x 768 resolution. Last updated April 2009. Over 1,194,000 page views.
This web site is maintained by Washington Publishers, Tallahassee Florida, USA, and uses Sun Domains and Software.
To have objectionable or potentially copyrighted material evaluated for removal on this site, click here.
Copyright © 2000 - 2009 All Rights Reserved Washington Publishers
Washington Publishers is not an affiliate of Inside Washington Publishers.
Learn more about our current privacy and information practices.